Remembering Jeff Pfister: A Legacy of Law, Family, and Community

Tavares, Florida, USA - In a profound loss for the Tavares community, Jeff Pfister, a beloved lawyer, father, and educator, passed away peacefully in his sleep at the age of 71 on May 28, 2025. He was not only dedicated to his craft but also deeply committed to his family, which included eight children. Among them is Terri Pfister, who serves as the principal at Seminole Springs Elementary School. His unexpected passing has left a notable void in both his family and the local legal community.

Pfister was born on October 31, 1953, in Lake County and graduated from Leesburg High School in 1971. He went on to earn a bachelor’s degree from the University of Notre Dame in 1975, before attending Florida State University Law School, where he completed his studies in 1977. Remarkably, he passed the Florida Bar exam on his first attempt in 1978, a testament to his diligent preparation and legal acumen. His early career began at the State Attorney’s Office for the 5th Judicial Circuit of Florida, and by 1985, he opened his own private practice.

A Legacy of Advocacy

Recognized as one of the first Board-Certified Criminal Trial Attorneys in Florida, Pfister remained active in the legal field until his death. He was inducted into the Lake County Schools Alumni Hall of Fame in 2023, a fitting tribute to his longstanding commitment to education as well as law. His clients often benefitted from his compassionate approach, especially in juvenile cases, where he combined legal expertise with a genuine desire to help young clients succeed academically.

Known for his skill and passion for the law, Pfister dedicated himself fully to each case he undertook, embodying the highest standards of the legal profession. His commitment to the community extended beyond the courtroom; he taught Sunday School for 27 years and was heavily involved in various church activities as a devout Catholic.

Remembering a Loving Family Man

Jeff Pfister leaves behind a vibrant family, including his wife of 33 years, Lori A. Pfister, eight children, numerous grandchildren, and a great-granddaughter. His family was of paramount importance to him, and through his life and values, he instilled a sense of integrity and responsibility in them. Friends and colleagues have described him as a compassionate, skilled, and generous individual—with a heart full of love for his family and passion for his work.

A funeral mass is scheduled for June 20 at St. Patrick Catholic Church in Mount Dora, followed by a celebration of life at O’Keefe’s Irish Pub & Restaurant in Tavares. As the community gathers to honor his memory, there’s little doubt that Pfister’s impact on those he leaves behind will resonate for years to come.

In the legal world, Pfister’s contributions remind many of the importance of advocacy and mentorship, elements that continue to drive professionals like John Romano, a board-certified civil trial advocate. Romano emphasizes the necessity of commitment in trial law. He is known for his extensive knowledge, having litigated nearly every type of civil and criminal case throughout almost 50 years of practice. His involvement in trial advocacy training across America underscores the importance of nurturing the next generation of attorneys, much like Pfister did in his community.

As we reflect on Jeff Pfister’s life, it’s clear that he was not just a figure in the legal field but a dedicated father, husband, educator, and community member whose legacy will be cherished and carried forward by all who knew him.