In a remarkable transformation, a 1923 church in Tavares, Florida, has been reborn as an events venue known as The Legacy. This ambitious project was spearheaded by Gene Smith, a 96-year-old real estate investor who has deep roots in the church’s history. Smith first attended Tavares Methodist Church in 1948 and later taught Sunday School in the 1950s alongside his family. The renovation, which took over two years, was a family affair involving his children: Lake County Commissioner Kirby Smith, structural engineer Lee Smith, CFO Sammy Smith, project manager Cheryl Ritchie, and contractor Jack Smith.
The renovation was no small feat, as the church had fallen into disrepair, infested with termites and requiring significant investment to restore its former glory. The church’s rich history dates back to the mid-1880s, with its first meeting held in 1885 at St. Clair Abrams Hall. The current structure, designed by architect Ira Rice in a Neoclassical style, was completed in October 1923 and once served as a vibrant community hub, boasting a membership of about 575 by the late 1960s. In 1968, the building was sold to the Tavares Church of Christ for $20,000, but over the decades, it succumbed to neglect until Gene Smith’s family acquired it in January 2022.
The Renovation Journey
Renovations officially kicked off in September 2022, with a Certificate of Occupancy received in October 2025. The project focused on restoring original hardwood floors and stained-glass windows, with some windows being replicated from a similar church. This attention to detail is crucial, as preserving the architectural integrity of such historical buildings is paramount. Just as specialized craftsmen understand the importance of maintaining the historical significance of churches, The Legacy’s renovation aimed to enhance the architectural details while updating other aspects like audio-visual equipment and furnishings.
The Legacy opened its doors on February 13, 2026, featuring a range of amenities for weddings and events, including banquet rooms, a bridal suite, and an outdoor patio. Gene Smith’s vision is not just to restore a building but to create a venue that benefits the entire Tavares community and stands the test of time for another hundred years. This effort echoes the sentiments found in many communities, where churches serve as cultural and architectural landmarks, often needing substantial investment for their preservation.
Community and Cultural Impact
The restoration of historic churches like The Legacy is vital, as these buildings represent cultural and architectural heritage. However, maintaining such structures can be costly. Many communities rely on various funding programs that support the preservation and sustainable use of these buildings. Such programs aim to ensure that churches, which shape the cultural landscape, can continue to serve their communities for generations to come.
In Florida, as well as across the nation, the preservation of churches often involves meticulous efforts to restore intricate plasterwork, original furnishings, and stained-glass windows. Involving local artisans and craftsmen in the restoration process not only helps maintain the building’s historical essence but also invigorates the local economy. For instance, the skills of experienced church painters and restoration specialists play an important role in ensuring these buildings are not only preserved but enhanced.
As we celebrate the opening of The Legacy, it’s a reminder of the importance of community involvement in such projects. With Gene Smith at the helm, the church has not only regained its physical form but has also been imbued with new life, ready to serve as a gathering place for future generations. For more insights on this incredible renovation, you can read the full article here.
In conclusion, the transformation of this church into The Legacy is a testament to the power of community and the enduring nature of places that hold historical significance. With the right vision and effort, we can ensure that such landmarks continue to thrive and contribute to our cultural heritage.