Today is May 8, 2026, and there’s exciting news for ice cream lovers in Ponce Inlet! Lighthouse Ice Cream has made a big move, relocating to a fresh new spot at 4940 S. Peninsula Drive, right in front of the Hidden Treasure Rum Bar & Grill. If you’re wondering about the old place, it used to sit across from the Ponce Inlet Lighthouse & Museum, but alas, the lease wasn’t renewed. Still, the new location opened its doors in late April, and locals couldn’t be happier.
What’s even better? This delightful ice cream shop is open every day, rain or shine, so there’s no excuse not to stop by for a sweet treat! Owners Kim Canny and Heather Highfield are all about community connections and traditions, making sure that their shop feels like a warm hug from your hometown. They’ve managed to keep the nostalgic spirit alive, even though the new digs are a bit cozier, shrinking from 1,500 square feet to just 260! They no longer offer food—just ice cream—leaning on Hidden Treasure for those savory bites.
New Flavors and Community Spirit
The menu is a real scoop of joy, featuring hand-scooped Hershey’s Ice Cream flavors, floats, traditional sundaes, and the whimsical “Sand Pail Sundaes.” And if you’re looking for something refreshing, check out their new eight flavors of Hyppo fruit pops made with real fruit—perfect for those hot Florida days! The shop currently employs around 20 team members, mostly high school and college students, giving local youth a chance to work in a fun environment.
Despite the change in size and location, Lighthouse Ice Cream remains deeply committed to supporting local events and organizations. They truly embody the spirit of Ponce Inlet—a community staple that brings people together over delicious ice cream. Plus, they’re already looking toward the future, considering an expansion into downtown Daytona Beach. Now, how cool would that be?
Challenges and Strategies for Success
Running an ice cream shop isn’t all sprinkles and sunshine, though. The industry faces its share of challenges, including seasonality and competition with other leisure activities. Local marketing plays a crucial role in standing out in this competitive landscape. It’s not just about having the best ice cream; it’s about creating a welcoming space that feels like home. Engaging with customers through social media and local events is vital. It helps build a loyal customer base and enhances brand awareness.
Moreover, sustainability is becoming increasingly important for consumers. Ice cream shops like Lighthouse can attract new customers by utilizing local ingredients and eco-friendly practices. A robust online presence is essential these days, too. Keeping profiles updated and engaging with the community through social media platforms like Facebook and Instagram can make all the difference. Positive online reviews can significantly boost trust among potential customers, and let’s not forget the power of email marketing to foster customer loyalty.
As Lighthouse Ice Cream continues to navigate its new chapter, it’s clear that they’re not just about serving ice cream; they’re about building connections and creating lasting memories. So, whether you’re a longtime fan or a first-time visitor, grab your favorite flavor and enjoy the sweet taste of community!
For more details on their move and offerings, check out the full article here.