In the early hours of Saturday, April 25, 2026, a dramatic incident unfolded on Pigeon Key, a charming island in the heart of the Florida Keys. Nicholas Robert Matott, a 37-year-old from Key West, made headlines when he leapt over the perimeter gate of the island, attempting to break into staff accommodations reports the Tampa Free Press.
The Monroe County Sheriff’s Office received a call regarding an intruder at 1:15 a.m. A woman staying overnight at the facility was alerted by the motion-activated lights triggered by Matott’s unauthorized access. When she confronted him, insisting that the premises were closed, Matott refused to leave, escalating the situation. He even attempted to break into her bedroom where she had barricaded herself for safety.
A Pigeon Key Delight
For those unfamiliar, Pigeon Key is not just another slice of paradise; it’s rich with history. Nestled halfway along the Old Seven Mile Bridge, the island is a remnant of the Florida Keys’ storied past. Once privately owned and largely inaccessible to the public, it reopened in January 2022 after extensive restoration work. Now, visitors can enjoy a lovely tram ride from the Pigeon Key Visitor’s Center to the island, which covers five acres and features eleven historic buildings notes Florida Rambler.
Pigeon Key was once a hub for workers who built the Seven Mile Bridge from 1908 to 1912. The island has a unique charm with picnic facilities, a marine science center, and opportunities for snorkeling amidst the beautiful waters. Tours last about two hours, with daily departures of the tram at various times. Admission prices are quite reasonable at $28 for adults and $20 for children aged 4-12.
Crime Trends in Florida
While Pigeon Key could easily be mistaken for a tranquil escape, it exists within the broader context of Florida’s complex crime landscape. The state has been noted for having one of the highest crime rates in the U.S., with property crimes such as burglary and theft being particularly prevalent according to ESTA Formular.
Specifically, the overall crime rate in Florida hit approximately 3,017.5 incidents per 100,000 residents in 2019, with Opa-locka and Florida City standing out as two of the most dangerous cities. Interestingly, while areas like Miami Beach attract many tourists, they still retain a relatively low violent crime rate, although petty theft remains a concern for visitors.
Matott was eventually found hiding under a nearby structure by deputies, who also discovered that he was in possession of a cell phone and charger belonging to a resident of the island. He now faces multiple charges for breaking and entering and remains in custody as investigations continue.
The recent incident serves as a stark reminder that even picturesque locales like Pigeon Key can be touched by criminal activity. However, it doesn’t diminish the allure of the island or the historical significance woven into the very fabric of the Florida Keys.