Discover Sarasota's Hidden Gems: 5 Must-Visit Old Florida Restaurants!

Bradenton, Florida - As we enjoy the sunny days and balmy nights of Florida, the dining scene in Sarasota and Manatee continues to celebrate its rich culinary heritage. Not just any dining, but a refreshing mix of Old Florida-style cuisine that invites you to kick back in your flip-flops. Local eateries known for their character, comfort food, and inviting settings are thriving, with options that won’t break the bank.

The Herald-Tribune highlights five standout restaurants in the area that embody this spirit of casual dining. Let’s take a closer look at these delightful spots.

Old Florida Favorites

• Duffy’s Tavern (Anna Maria Island) – Located at 5808 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, this gem has been welcoming patrons since 1971. With a reputation for delicious burgers and a cash-only policy, Duffy’s offers a relaxed atmosphere to savor island gossip over a diner-style cheeseburger. Phone: 941-778-2501.
• J.R.’s Old Packinghouse Cafe (Sarasota) – This cafe opened its doors in 1999 in a charming building from the 1950s. With live music six nights a week, J.R.’s serves hearty comfort dishes, including Miami-style Cuban sandwiches and the beloved blackened Ybor Burger. Visit them at 987 S. Packinghouse Road, Sarasota. Phone: 941-371-9358.
• Linger Lodge (Bradenton) – Established in 1945 along the scenic Braden River, this spot brings Southern flavors to the forefront, featuring everything from frog legs to Gulf seafood. Curious diners will appreciate its quirky decor adorned with taxidermy. Find it at 7205 85th St. Court E., Bradenton. Phone: 941-755-2757.
• New Pass Grill & Bait Shop (Sarasota) – Since the 1950s, this combination bait shack and burger stand has been known for cheeseburgers with a view. Open daily from 7 a.m. to 6 p.m. at 1505 Ken Thompson Parkway, it’s the perfect casual getaway. Phone: 941-388-1618.
• Skinny’s Place (Anna Maria Island) – Renowned for its „Skinny Cheeseburger,“ this eatery has been around since 1964, boasting both indoor and outdoor seating near the beach. Located at 3901 Gulf Drive, Holmes Beach. Phone: 941-778-7769.

These venues reflect Sarasota’s love for relaxed dining, where patrons can enjoy a meal without the fuss. But it’s not just about the classics; the area’s dining scene is evidently evolving.

A Look Back and Forward

In a nostalgic turn, an article from Closed Down Restaurants highlights the numerous eateries that have come and gone in Sarasota. Despite its current population of around 57,000, the city’s culinary landscape has seen many changes over the years, including restaurants like two Howard Johnson’s that are now a government office and a Taco Bell.

The history of Sarasota as a fishing village has deeply influenced its cuisine, favoring fresh seafood dishes like mahi-mahi tacos and Cuban sandwiches. Even Zota Beach Resort captures this essence with its ocean views and innovative seafood options made from locally sourced ingredients.

Sarasota’s Growing Dining Scene

Sarasota’s dining scene is not only rich in tradition but also bursting with new growth, as noted in another piece from Willa Q Clarine. With over 1,000 restaurants and 125,000 reviews on TripAdvisor, the area is recognized as a hotspot for culinary exploration. New eateries have been sprouting up, focusing on diverse offerings – from Italian to sushi, and even a flourishing vegan scene.

Indeed, 2023 alone saw the emergence of 10 new restaurants that have garnered attention, adding to the vibrant palette of choices available to locals and visitors alike. Whether you’re craving fried chicken or a beautifully crafted seafood dish, Sarasota manages to have it all.

As the summer unfolds, exploring these dining treasures—both old and new—will surely tantalize your taste buds and keep you coming back for more. What’s your favorite spot to unwind over a meal in Sarasota? With such a diverse and vibrant mix, there’s always something new to discover.